In partnership with

Your daily edge in private markets

Wondering what’s the latest with crypto treasury companies, Pre-IPO venture secondaries, private credit deals and real estate moves? Join 100,000+ private market investors who get smarter every day with Alternative Investing Report, the industry's leading source for investing in alternative assets.

In your inbox by 9 AM ET, AIR is chock full of the latest insights, analysis and trends that are driving alts. Readers get a weekly investment pick to consider from a notable investor, plus special offers to join top private market platforms and managers.

And the best part? It’s totally free forever.

Subcribe to AIR today

When BIGGER Makes You Richer

If you're looking for the best way to juice your resale price in a booming market, adding square footage is the heavy-lift play that separates investors from amateurs.

Let’s break it down.

1. What’s a Square Foot Play?

A “square foot play” is exactly what it sounds like: adding usable living area to a home to increase its value. It can take several forms:

• Popping the top: Adding a second story

• Rear/side bump-outs: Extending the footprint horizontally

• Finishing basements or attics: As long as it meets code (egress, ceiling height, heat), it counts

• Garage conversions: Tricky, but can work in the right neighborhoods

This isn’t lipstick-on-a-pig remodeling. This is major surgery—and when done right, it can make you a killing.

2. When It Makes Sense

You don’t do this in every neighborhood. You do it when you spot a hot high-dollar flip—your phrase, Roger, and it’s dead-on.

Picture this: a 1,200 sq ft 1950s bungalow in a now-booming neighborhood full of $2M new builds. It's surrounded by modern homes with open layouts, 5-piece baths, and enough closet space to hide your contractor’s mistakes. Your old bones-on-the-block needs more than shiplap to compete.

Adding square footage isn’t about square footage. It’s about market positioning.

• You do it when the neighborhood supports it.

• You do it when buyers expect it.

• You do it when there’s a massive gap between the current and potential value.

If new builds are selling for $500/sq ft and you're buying at $250/sq ft, you've got a spread worth chasing.

3. The Challenges

This isn’t a paint-and-carpet weekend warrior special. It’s a high-wire act with five inspectors watching.

Zoning & Permitting

• Local zoning codes may limit height, setbacks, or total square footage.

• Historic districts? Say hello to the Design Review Committee, aka the people who hate your profit.

• Some municipalities restrict “pop tops” entirely.

Lot Coverage Ratio

• Most cities have a maximum percentage of the lot that can be covered by the structure.

• Example: If your lot is 5,000 sq ft and the max coverage is 40%, you’re capped at 2,000 sq ft—unless you go up.

Structural Load

• Want to pop the top? Better check that those 1948 floor joists weren’t made from leftover fence posts.

• You’ll likely need engineering, reinforced footers, and a beefy checkbook.

Utilities and Systems

• New square footage often means upgrading HVAC, electrical, and plumbing.

• You'll also need to relocate or reroute infrastructure (e.g., vent stacks, gas lines, electrical service panels).

Permitting Delays

• Depending on your market, you could be waiting weeks—or months—for permits.

• And that’s before your GC goes “off-grid” for two weeks fishing in Alabama.

4. Cost vs. Return

This is where rookies get hurt and pros get paid.

Your Rule of Thumb: 2-for-1 ROI

If you spend $100K adding square footage, you should see at least a $200K bump in resale value. Anything less and you're in “do it for the experience” territory—and last I checked, experience doesn’t pay back your hard money lender.

Some ballpark costs:

• Popping the Top: $200–$300/sq ft in most markets

• Lateral Additions: $150–$250/sq ft

• Basement Finishes: $50–$120/sq ft (if legal)

• Garage Conversions: $40–$100/sq ft (but often discounted by appraisers)

Caveat: These are national averages. If you’re in San Francisco or Manhattan, add a zero. If you're in rural Arkansas, subtract a contractor.

The Secret Sauce:

• Keep the cost per added foot below the neighborhood’s average resale per foot, and

• Only do it in places where buyers will actually pay a premium for more space.

5. The Strategic Advantage

Let’s say you find a small, dated home in a high-dollar ZIP. It’s listed near full retail, and every other flipper walks away because there’s “no room to profit.”

But you? You run the square foot play.

You bump it from 1,100 to 2,000 sq ft with a killer layout and high-end finishes, and you’re suddenly competing with the $900K homes down the street—not the tired $550K fixers in the same zip.

In hot areas, you can pay near full price and still win—because you're playing a different game.

6. The Cautions (a.k.a. Things That Keep You Up at Night)

Time is your enemy.

These projects can take 6–9 months, or longer if your contractor ghosts you mid-pour.

Interest eats profits.

Every month on a hard money loan chips away at your margin. A $400K loan at 12% is $4,000/month—before you lift a hammer.

Contractor Risk is Real.

This is not the time to “try out a new guy” or go with your cousin’s handyman. You need a licensed, experienced, schedule-obsessed GC who can manage subs, city inspectors, and stress levels.

Scope Creep is inevitable.

“Oh while we’re here, let’s move the kitchen” turns into “might as well rewire the whole house.”

And just like that, your 2-for-1 margin becomes 1-for-1—and you’re flipping for practice.

7. The Final Word

Adding square footage is not for the faint of heart. It’s expensive, risky, and complicated. But when the market is right, the numbers work, and the team is solid—it’s one of the most powerful profit strategies in your playbook.

Just remember: Bigger isn't always better.

Founders need better information

Get a single daily brief that filters the noise and delivers the signals founders actually use.

All the best stories — curated by a founder who reads everything so you don't have to.

And it’s totally free. We pay to subscribe, you get the good stuff.

Get the brief