Landlord Lawsuits - How To Avoid Them

If you wind up in court, you've already lost.

In Partnership With

Landlording in a Lawsuit World

Being a landlord today is nothing like it was twenty—even ten—years ago. Lawsuits are up, tenant expectations are higher, and one misunderstanding can turn into a six-month legal headache. The good news? Most investor-landlords get into trouble not because of bad tenants… but because of avoidable mistakes.

Today’s Quick Tip: how to protect yourself, your assets, and your sanity while operating rentals in a lawsuit-happy world.

1. Follow the Law—Not Your Gut

The number one cause of landlord lawsuits is uninformed decision-making.

Examples include:

  • Denying an applicant for the wrong reason

  • Mishandling security deposits

  • Improper notice before entry

  • Cutting corners on habitability repairs

Your intent doesn’t matter. The law does.

Spend an hour reading your state’s landlord-tenant handbook. Then bookmark it.

2. Document Everything (Because Your Memory Will Lose in Court)

Every text, receipt, work order, and maintenance request matters.

Keep:

  • Time-stamped photos

  • Written tenant communication

  • Itemized move-in/move-out forms

  • Proof of rent payments

If you ever find yourself in court, documentation is your best (and sometimes only) defense.

3. Don’t DIY the Lease Agreement

The fastest way to lose a lawsuit is with a lease downloaded from the internet.

Instead:

  • Use your state’s REALTOR® association lease

  • Or have an attorney create a custom one

  • Update it yearly—laws change

A strong lease prevents 80% of your future headaches.

4. Treat Tenants Like Customers, Not Problems

A surprising number of lawsuits come from tenants who simply felt ignored.

Good customer service prevents legal trouble:

  • Respond within 24 hours

  • Fix legitimate issues quickly

  • Stay respectful—even when tenants don’t

Professionalism is a shield.

5. Understand Insurance (Most Landlords Don’t)

Standard landlord insurance is NOT enough. Consider:

  • Umbrella coverage ($1–$5M is surprisingly affordable)

  • Loss-of-rent coverage

  • Liability for pets, guests, and contractors

Think of insurance as outsourced peace of mind.

6. Pick Your Battles Wisely

Sometimes the cheapest, smartest option is to:

  • Refund the security deposit

  • Reduce a fee

  • Offer a small settlement

Good landlords fight when they must—not when they’re angry.

Bottom Line

You don’t have to be afraid of lawsuits…

…but you do need to operate like a professional.

A structured process, solid documentation, responsive communication, and the right insurance will keep 99% of legal trouble away from your door.

Operate like a business, and the business will reward you.

We Just Made Off-Market a Lot More Visible

Off-market deals are still the lifeblood of real estate investors — even though we can snag good ones on the MLS, too.

Quick Tips now features Opportunities, a new platform where our subscribers can post and browse off-market deals.

We quietly launched it last week and already had 3,800+ visitors.
So picture this: your deal promoted across our entire network, reaching up to 2.1 million potential eyeballs in 30 days — all for our introductory rate of just $100.

You’re not imagining it. That’s the offer.
Click here to post your deal.

Breaking: Earning Markets are now LIVE on Polymarket 🚨

Turn a question into profit in one click with Polymarket’s new Earnings Markets. You can now trade yes/no on outcomes of your favorite companies:

  • Will Robinhood beat earnings?

  • Will Nvidia mention China?

  • Will Figma miss estimated EPS?

Earning Markets allow you to:

  • Trade simple Yes/No binary outcomes around earnings

  • Stay focused and isolate the specific event you want to trade

  • Be flexible with with entering, hedging, or exiting your position at any time

Upcoming markets include FIGMA, ROBINHOOD, AMC, NVIDIA, and more. Built for how traders actually trade.